Sleep Study vs Home Sleep Test If you suspect you have Sleep Apnea, the first step is testing. But here comes the question many patients ask: Should I take a full in-lab sleep study, or is a home sleep test enough?
In this blog, we’ll compare Sleep Study vs Home Sleep Test, explain how each works, highlight the pros and cons, and help you decide which option is right for you.
What is a Sleep Study (Polysomnography)?
A sleep study, also known as polysomnography (PSG), is an overnight test performed in a sleep clinic or hospital.
What it Measures:
-
Brain activity (EEG)
-
Breathing patterns
-
Heart rate
-
Oxygen levels
-
Muscle activity
-
Sleep stages (REM, non-REM)
Pros of a Sleep Study:
-
Highly accurate, considered the gold standard
-
Detects different sleep disorders (OSA, CSA, insomnia, narcolepsy)
-
Monitored by trained sleep specialists
Cons of a Sleep Study:
-
Requires spending the night at a clinic
-
More expensive than a home sleep test
-
Can feel less natural due to wires and sensors
What is a Home Sleep Test?
A Home Sleep Test (HST) is a portable device you wear at home while sleeping. It primarily measures breathing patterns and oxygen levels to screen for Obstructive Sleep Apnea (OSA).
Pros of a Home Sleep Test:
-
Convenient and comfortable (done in your own bed)
-
Lower cost compared to in-lab studies
-
Easier access, faster results
Cons of a Home Sleep Test:
-
Less detailed than a lab study (doesn’t measure brain waves)
-
Primarily screens for OSA, may miss other sleep disorders
-
Accuracy depends on correct device setup
Sleep Study vs Home Sleep Test: Key Differences
| Feature | Sleep Study (PSG) | Home Sleep Test (HST) |
|---|---|---|
| Location | Sleep lab/clinic | At home |
| Disorders Diagnosed | OSA, CSA, narcolepsy, insomnia | Mostly OSA |
| Accuracy | Gold standard, very detailed | Reliable for OSA, less detailed overall |
| Comfort | Clinical environment, many wires | Natural home environment |
| Cost | Higher | Lower |
| Insurance Coverage | Often covered | Often covered |
Which One Should You Choose?
-
If you have mild symptoms of OSA → A Home Sleep Test may be a good first step.
-
If you have complex symptoms (heart problems, CSA, insomnia, narcolepsy) → An in-lab Sleep Study is recommended.
-
If your doctor suspects more than OSA → Go for a full polysomnography.
FAQs (People Also Ask)
Q1. What is the difference between a sleep study and a home sleep test?
A sleep study is a lab-based, detailed test, while a home sleep test is portable and mainly screens for OSA.
Q2. Is a home sleep test accurate?
Yes, for diagnosing moderate to severe OSA. But it may miss other sleep disorders.
Q3. Who should do a lab sleep study instead of a home test?
Patients with heart disease, central sleep apnea, or unexplained sleep issues should go for a lab study.
Q4. Can insurance cover a home sleep test?
In many cases, yes. Most insurance providers cover home sleep tests if prescribed by a doctor.
Q5. Which test is more comfortable?
Most patients find a home sleep test more comfortable since it’s done in their own bed.